The Queensland Police Union wants mandatory prison terms for serious assaults on police, while a legal expert questions whether harsher penalties would deter attacks.

The Mount Isa case
The Mount Isa assault has sharpened a debate over Queensland’s response to violence against police. The state’s police union wants mandatory prison terms for serious attacks, arguing that a custodial sentence should follow; a legal academic doubts those terms would prevent assaults. The dispute turns on two different questions: what punishment should follow an offence, and whether changing that punishment would affect someone’s decision to commit it.
Two men, aged 26 and 24, have been charged over an alleged altercation involving three officers in Mount Isa at about 2:30am on October 30. A male officer was taken to hospital with injuries to his face. The charges are before the courts, so the allegations haven’t been tested in court and the case shouldn’t be treated as proof of guilt.

Shane Prior says the officer sustained cuts and substantial injuries to his cheek and nose. (Supplied: Queensland Police Union)
Queensland Police Union president Shane Prior says the incident underscores the need for stronger penalties. He wants mandatory minimum sentences for serious assaults on police, arguing that imprisonment should follow such attacks. That position treats a clear, predictable penalty as part of the response to violence against officers, as well as a way to signal how seriously the state regards the offence.
Prior, a former frontline officer, has spoken with the Mount Isa staff involved. He said the injured officer suffered damage to his cheekbone and upper jaw, along with a deep cut near his lip and nose. The account gives the union’s case a specific human focus, but the wider policy question still rests on whether a different sentencing rule would affect future conduct.
The sentencing debate
Prior says previous work on minimum sentences for serious assaults against emergency workers didn’t go far enough. That work followed a referral to the Queensland Sentencing Advisory Council by former attorney-general Yvette D’Ath. The council found that more than 90 per cent of the serious assaults it examined over a decade resulted in a custodial sentence. That finding suggests prison was already common in the cases reviewed, though it doesn’t by itself resolve whether a mandatory minimum would alter sentencing outcomes or deter offending.

Shane Prior wants the state government to introduce mandatory minimum sentencing for serious assaults on police. (ABC News: Mark Leonardi)
Queensland Sentencing Board figures show aggravated serious assault matters involving adult offenders rose from 220 in the 2019–20 financial year to 360 in the most recent financial year. Between 2020 and 2025, imprisonment was imposed in 48 per cent of sentenced matters involving serious assault on police; 20 per cent received wholly suspended sentences. These figures describe case volumes and sentencing outcomes, but don’t establish why those outcomes occurred or whether a mandatory floor would change the rate of assaults.
For Griffith University senior law lecturer Simon McKenzie, the figures don’t establish that mandatory terms would reduce assaults. He accepts the need to protect workers, but questions whether someone in a confrontation would weigh a minimum sentence before acting. Here’s the thing: a penalty can change the consequences after conviction without necessarily changing decisions made in a volatile moment. The numbers here are underwhelming as evidence of deterrence; they show what courts have imposed, not what offenders considered beforehand.

Simon McKenzie says there is little evidence to show mandatory minimum sentencing would reduce assault rates. (Supplied: Griffith University)
McKenzie also cautions that mandatory terms could increase prison numbers and make the justice system less efficient. If a defendant faces the same minimum penalty after pleading guilty, he said, there may be less incentive to admit the offence rather than contest it. That concern is about how a fixed penalty can affect the path of a case: if fewer defendants plead guilty, more matters may need to be resolved through contested proceedings.
And yet, the union’s argument isn’t answered simply by pointing to existing prison sentences. A mandatory minimum could make the outcome more predictable, while its critics question whether that predictability would prevent attacks or bring added costs elsewhere in the justice process. The available figures don’t settle that debate. If you’re working in this space, the distinction matters: tougher sentencing can be presented as a response to harm even when its deterrent effect remains uncertain.
Government response
The Queensland government passed mandatory minimum sentencing laws for bail breaches last month, with those laws due to take effect at the end of November. Attorney-General Deb Frecklington didn’t say whether similar measures for assaults on police were under consideration. She said the government remained committed to community safety and would strengthen laws where required. That response leaves open whether the state will take up the union’s request, and on what grounds it would assess such a change.
The union is urging the attorney-general to start drafting reforms. The Mount Isa case has brought that demand back into focus, while the disagreement over deterrence leaves a central question unresolved: would tougher minimum penalties change behaviour, or mainly reshape what happens after an assault? For now, the case itself remains before the courts, and the policy argument is broader than its allegations.
What the debate leaves unresolved
The dispute is about more than the length of a sentence. It asks what evidence should support a change in sentencing policy, and how decision-makers should weigh punishment, deterrence and the way cases move through court. The figures cited here can inform that discussion, but they don’t answer every part of it.
This is more significant than it looks: the choice of a mandatory minimum would affect how much room courts have to account for the circumstances of a case, while the claimed public safety benefit remains contested in the material presented here. That said, the government’s response hasn’t confirmed a proposal or set out a timetable. The next question is whether the union’s demand becomes a concrete reform debate, with the expected effects examined rather than assumed.
A sentencing rule can be changed on paper. The harder question is what it changes in practice.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.