Collingwood will bring in an external consultant to review its AFLW program as coach Sam Wright and captain Ruby Schleicher prepare to leave.
Collingwood’s AFLW program faces a strategic review after a season of poor results and the imminent departures of coach Sam Wright and captain Ruby Schleicher. The club says it accepts responsibility for its performance and will bring in an external consultant to help identify changes. The review arrives at a moment when results, leadership and player movement are all in question, making it a test of how clearly the club can diagnose the problems behind a difficult stretch.
A record that has fallen short
The Magpies have managed one win this season and sit second-last. Across the past three seasons, they have won five games and lost 29. Those figures describe more than a poor run of form: they point to a sustained failure to turn a season into consistent results, though the record alone can’t explain why. A review will need to consider the causes rather than treat the win-loss tally as a diagnosis.
Wright will coach his final game against Essendon on Sunday at Windy Hill. Schleicher is also leaving at season’s end to return to Western Australia, while reports point to further player departures. Losing a coach and captain at the same time creates an obvious leadership gap. If more players depart, the club will also face questions about continuity and how the group will be rebuilt, though the reports don’t establish who else may leave or what their reasons might be.
Collingwood president Barry Carp said the review would be conducted with the club’s AFLW sub-committee. An outside expert, he said, could bring a broader perspective and challenge existing approaches. That choice suggests the club wants a process capable of questioning familiar assumptions, rather than relying only on the people already responsible for the program. The value of that approach will depend on whether the review can identify specific causes and lead to changes that people inside the club can act on.
Club acknowledges the need for change
“The board, together with the executive team, acknowledges that we haven't got it right — we take responsibility for that and are committed to getting better, both on and off the field,” Carp said in a club statement.
He described the AFLW program as integral to Collingwood and said the club was committed to building it for sustained success. Carp added that the club had a responsibility to listen to players, staff, members, supporters and the wider game, and to make considered changes. That list matters because a review can produce very different conclusions depending on whose experience is heard. Listening widely won’t resolve competing views on its own, but it can help the club distinguish a shared problem from a disagreement about what the program should become.
Former AFLW player and coach Lauren Arnell has criticised Collingwood’s standard of play. She has also stressed that coaches have a responsibility to “put on a show” as the competition seeks to grow. That criticism places the discussion beyond the club’s own record. In a competition seeking to attract attention, performance is part of the public case a team makes for its place and ambition. The phrase “put on a show” is a reminder that supporters and viewers judge the experience as well as the result.
This is more significant than it looks: accepting responsibility is a useful first step, but it isn’t evidence that the review will change the program. The harder work is deciding which parts of the current approach have failed and then following through. A statement can set a tone. It can’t, by itself, repair performances or persuade players that the conditions for improvement are in place.
Several coaching roles in play
Wright’s final match will also be the last for Essendon coach Natalie Wood. St Kilda is seeking a new coach following Nick Dal Santo’s departure, while expansion side Tasmania is also looking for a coach. Collingwood’s review will now determine what changes the club believes are needed to strengthen its AFLW program.
Several vacancies across the competition make the coaching picture a wider part of the story, but the available facts don’t show what those clubs are seeking or how their searches will proceed. For Collingwood, the immediate issue is more specific: the review must help the club understand what it needs from its next phase of leadership. A change of coach may be one outcome, but the announcement doesn’t say that the review has reached any conclusion about its scope or recommendations.
What the review needs to resolve
External reviews are often most useful when they turn broad concerns into questions that can be answered: what isn’t working, where responsibility sits, and which changes could address the problem. Collingwood has acknowledged that it needs to improve on and off the field, but it hasn’t yet identified the source of the poor results. That leaves a wide brief. The consultant and sub-committee will have to weigh performance alongside the experience of players and staff, while avoiding the temptation to treat one departing coach or captain as a complete explanation.
(And this is the part most people overlook.) A strategic review can only be as useful as the decisions that follow it. Players, staff and supporters may hear the language of accountability and sustained success as a promise; the club will need to show what that means in practice. If you're working in this space, the challenge will sound familiar: gathering honest feedback is one task, turning it into choices that people can see is another.
Collingwood’s record gives the club a clear reason to examine its AFLW program. The departures add urgency, while the external consultant offers a way to question existing thinking. What comes next will depend on whether the review produces a clear account of the problems and a credible response. For now, the club has named the need for change. The specifics are still to come.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.