Court records show Bathla-linked companies missed payment deadlines on land deals worth $130 million, raising questions about their ability to secure funding.
A $3.4 billion collapse, preceded by stalled deals
Bathla’s collapse followed a pattern that land sellers had already encountered: companies linked to the developer agreed to buy property, then struggled to complete. ABC News identified three such transactions worth a combined $130 million, with sellers turning to the courts after deadlines passed. The clearest example involved Michael Ryan’s $39.5 million property in Sydney’s north-west. After Bathla missed settlement dates and lost a court battle over the delay, Ryan effectively had to lend money to the company buying his land. That’s a striking outcome for a group that reported more than $2.59 billion in assets and over $62 million in after-tax profit in 2021–22.
The parcel in Box Hill, previously owned by Michael Ryan, was at the centre of a legal dispute with Bathla Group. (ABC News: Berge Breiland)
A former major lender believes Bathla expanded too quickly, especially in its later years, leaving it exposed as property conditions weakened. The court cases give that view some weight: they point to trouble raising funds at the moment payments fell due. They don’t, by themselves, explain the full causes of the group’s eventual collapse.
A deal repeatedly pushed back
Ryan agreed to a put-and-call option with Bathla subsidiary UPG 322 in October 2021, a common way for a developer to secure land for a later purchase. Bathla exercised the option about a year later, and the parties signed a sale contract the following month. The first settlement date, in April 2023, came and went. So did further deadlines in May and October. Ryan took UPG 322 to the NSW Supreme Court, which ordered the sale to complete in November. That deadline passed too.
This Box Hill parcel, formerly owned by Bathla Group, is now under receivers’ control. (ABC News: Berge Breiland)
Penny Cable, the McCabes Lawyers property group head who represented Ryan, said one settlement attempt fell apart at the last minute.
> “We were ready to go all day, and then at four o'clock they pulled the pin and said, 'Financier is not coming to the party,'” she said.
Ryan declined to speak to ABC News.
Lawyer Penny Cable believes Bathla missed deadlines while seeking funding. (ABC News: Daniel Irvine)
Assets on paper, financing in question
Court records show that the Bathla-linked buyer had difficulty finding the money to settle. After missing the court-ordered November 2023 deadline, its lawyers told Ryan’s solicitor they could not secure the necessary finance. Three months later, the company produced a term sheet from private credit firm Alceon. It covered less than 60 per cent of the original price, was conditional, and explicitly wasn’t an offer of finance. The judge called the evidence that Bathla could complete the purchase “flimsy and unconvincing”. He also noted that founder Bhart Bhushan, a guarantor on the deal, had not explained why he failed to comply with the court orders: “this does not count in his favour”. Those funding problems sat alongside the group’s reported assets and profits. Insolvency specialist Brian Silvia, principal of CasCap Advisory, said cash flow and financing issues could account for the apparent mismatch.
Brian Silvia says repeated delays in settling land deals can point to deeper financial problems. (ABC News: Geoff Kemp)
> “There can be a disconnect between profits and the ability to finance the acquisition of properties,” he said.
Ryan’s eventual solution was to lend money to the buyer so it could complete the purchase. In a December 2023 ruling, the judge said the group’s reported financial position—and a separate $13.6 million property purchase by another subsidiary while Ryan was still waiting—raised questions about why Bhushan had not arranged for UPG 322 to settle.
More sellers, more stalled purchases
Cable said three other landowners contacted her after running into problems with Bathla-related buyers. The offers could be attractive, she said, but a failed settlement left vendors with a hard choice: keep the deposit and walk away, or pursue the deal while trying to find another buyer in a weaker market, potentially at a much lower price. > “It was really awful to see that it wasn't just my client, but then other people coming out to say this is happening to me as well,” she said. > “From a vendor's perspective, it's awful. This is a big company and they're not completing.” Court documents describe two more troubled purchases. Bathla subsidiary UPG 318 failed to settle a $20.6 million purchase for another Box Hill property. In September 2024, the NSW Supreme Court ordered it to complete the deal.
Box Hill and nearby suburbs in Sydney’s north-west were a major focus of Bathla Group’s residential projects. (ABC News: Berge Breiland)
In the other case, Raj & Jai (Mudgee) Pty Ltd defaulted on a $70 million agreement to acquire interests in a partly developed regional NSW estate. The purchaser was a subsidiary of Raj & Jai Construction, one of the companies that entered administration as part of the Bathla Group’s collapse this August.
The NSW Supreme Court ordered the purchaser to complete the transaction in June 2025 and directed it and its parent company to pay default interest. Less than a month later, Raj & Jai (Mudgee) was renamed Mudgee Properties and entered liquidation.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.